The Clear Cooperation Policy (CCP), introduced by the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR) in 2019 and implemented in 2020, mandates that real estate agents list a property on their Multiple Listing Service (MLS) within one business day of publicly marketing it. This policy aims to enhance market transparency and ensure equal access to property listings. However, it has sparked considerable debate within the real estate community, with proponents and opponents presenting compelling arguments.

Understanding the Clear Cooperation Policy

The CCP was established to address the growing prevalence of off-market or “pocket” listings, where properties are marketed privately without being listed on the MLS. Such practices were particularly common in luxury markets, where exclusive networks shared listings among select agents and buyers. NAR’s policy requires that once a property is publicly marketed—through websites, yard signs, social media, or other means—it must be submitted to the MLS within one business day. Exceptions exist for “office exclusives,” where marketing is confined within a single brokerage.

Arguments in Favor of the Clear Cooperation Policy

1. Enhanced Market Transparency: By ensuring that publicly marketed properties are listed on the MLS, the CCP promotes a more transparent marketplace. This openness allows all buyers and agents to access comprehensive information about available properties, fostering fair competition.

2. Maximized Seller Exposure: Listing properties on the MLS exposes them to a broader audience, potentially leading to higher sale prices and quicker transactions. Research indicates that homes listed on the MLS often sell for more than those sold off-market.

3. Support for Fair Housing Principles: An open MLS ensures that all buyers, regardless of background, have equal access to property listings, aligning with fair housing laws and promoting inclusivity in the housing market.

4. Data Accuracy and Market Analysis: Comprehensive MLS listings contribute to accurate market data, aiding agents and consumers in making informed decisions based on current market conditions and comparable sales.

Arguments Against the Clear Cooperation Policy

1. Limitations on Seller Autonomy: Critics argue that the CCP restricts sellers’ rights to choose how to market their properties. Some sellers, particularly those seeking privacy—such as celebrities or individuals in sensitive situations—may prefer off-market transactions to maintain discretion.

2. Potential Negative Market Perceptions: Mandatory MLS listings can lead to public records of price reductions and days on the market, which some believe may negatively impact a property’s perceived value. Sellers prefer to test pricing strategies privately before committing to a public listing.

3. Brokerage Competition Concerns: Some large brokerages contend that the CCP limits their ability to leverage exclusive listings as a competitive advantage. They argue that repealing the policy could allow for more tailored marketing strategies that benefit their clients.

4. Legal and Regulatory Scrutiny: The CCP has attracted attention from regulatory bodies, including the Department of Justice, over concerns that it may stifle competition and limit alternative platforms. Ongoing legal challenges suggest that the policy’s future may be uncertain.

Current Status and Ongoing Debate

As of December 2024, the Clear Cooperation Policy remains a contentious issue within the real estate industry. NAR continues to evaluate the policy, considering feedback from various stakeholders and the implications of ongoing legal proceedings. The debate centers on balancing the benefits of market transparency and fairness with the need for flexibility and autonomy in property marketing strategies.

The Clear Cooperation Policy was designed to create a more equitable and transparent real estate market by ensuring publicly marketed properties are accessible through the MLS. While it offers significant fairness and data accuracy benefits, it raises concerns about seller autonomy and market strategy flexibility. As the industry grapples with these issues, real estate professionals should stay informed about developments related to the CCP and consider how best to serve their clients within the evolving regulatory landscape.

Experience More with Fathom Realty

Why settle for the status quo when you can have more with Fathom Realty? Embrace the future of real estate with our cutting-edge technology, extensive training, and dedicated local support. It’s Your Business. You Should Be Able to Choose. Your Choice. Your Plan. Your Future. Come Grow With Us. With our industry-leading Fathom Max and Fathom Share commission plans, you decide how to grow your business and maximize your potential. Are you ready to experience more from your broker? Let’s connect and discuss how Fathom Realty can help you achieve your goals.